back

by srean·15y ago·view on hn ↗
Is it only me who finds "Ask Prateek" tad conceited ? I am none too comfortable with the idea of helping oneself to someone else's work/brand unless it was expressly opened for that purpose. But then imitation may be the sincerest form of flattery.

It doesnt help much that the Indian software scene has a stronger reputation for copying than for innovating. And I am Indian. I have similar minor peeves about OSQA helping themselves to SO. But I take back my comments if the news.ycombinator src as well as the brand were indeed opened up for that purpose.

Edit: "Ask Prateek" is "Ask HNI" now, so I take back that part of my criticism.

1 comments
The reason we are using the HN codebase is because it has been proven to work (socially and not just technically). Since this is a not a for profit initiative (no ads/links), there is no sense investing time in reinventing it when this just works.
By that logic one can justify any form of plagiarism cant one ? I am more concerned about helping yourself to the brand without permission than about using the code as its on git.

It just reinforces the stereotype that Indian software scene is all about unauthorized copying of other people's ideas. I dont necessarily agree with the stereotype but things like this does not really help dispell it.