back
56 comments
Or follow yourself on RSS

https://hnrss.org/replies?id=

Nice, more power to RSS. Really digging that it's making a slow but steady comeback into more and more commonplace scenarios again.
That is perfect, thanks for sharing.
What do we pass in the id ?
Wow this is actually pretty useful Thanks for sharing
I love it, thanks!
right on! thank you.
I’d love to use this. A privacy notice would be cool.

There’s surely a huge liability in maintaining a database of (HN username, email) pairs. It’s a valuable target that will attract attention and I’m wary of becoming part of a breach.

So: a small privacy statement would be great to see, and maybe a note on security measures in place?

Apologies to DG if I’ve been living under a rock and you are a leading figure in Security research whose reputation I should know!

Excellent point.
I thought making difficult for one to see replies on their posts was intentional and a “feature” of HN. Avoid flame wars and all.

Edit: But having said that, this tool can come really handy in some cases

But not all conversations are "flame wars" , sometime you are having an interesting conversation/debate and you need a large amount of effort to remember to check for the replies and continue the thread.

I know that some HNers will say HN > Reddit but this is in general I know some subbreddits that are better then HN and if you use those is great to see when somebody responded to your quality comment with an other quality comment.

Reddit is polite 4chan. HN is pun-free and witty quip-less Reddit.

Humans are on average dumb pedantic jerks in internet comment sections everywhere. Some comment sections just have norms of conduct that do a better job masking it and making the people who can't mask it feel unwelcome. On HN we engage in mental gymnastics to avoid being wrong. On Reddit when people can't win they reply "yikes" or "who hurt you" and create an ad-hominum. On the chans they just call you a racial slur of some sort.

Reddit is not one place, there are subreddits, there are good ones with good moderation , but I do not participate in politics or heated topics.

As an example you could compare r/starttrek vs r/DaystromInstitute , in the first you will find tons of low effort content and comments (memes, bad jokes,personal attacks, off topic stuff) int he second one only on topic and medium effor comments are allowed.

I've been using this for about three years and had multiple times where people contacted me days after a comment–usually they're quite good.
Yeah. I prefer not being notified.
Reddit replies 10 years ago used to feel like an exciting thing. Nowadays, I just feel dread.
Before hnreplies, I was manually scanning my history for replies. It got fairly time consuming, and I didn't like the relationship I was forming with my comment scores, which I had to look at all the time. I've found that replies coming to my inbox is very different from reply notifications on the site. I'm not already in "browsing mode" and the email contains the full comment; at least half the time I don't bother clicking the link in the email. YMMV.
I love to go through my comments every so often and see the people who uselessly asked me questions or for more context.
there are no features on HN they just never developed it lol
This is pretty neat, though I do have mixed feelings. On one hand, HN is great because it's more like a "fun things to read" aggregator to me so I don't want HN to become like a psuedo reddit. On the other hand, I feel like I have missed a lot of fun conversations because I didn't know someone replied to me and missed the window to reply since the other person wouldn't know about my response either.
I have very mixed feelings about this.

The quality of HN threads benefits from more thought out comments and fewer reflexive replies. Notifications can promote “engagement” in the superficial sense of increasing frequency of replies, but will damage engagement in the deeper sense of decreasing depth of thought.

> HN to become like a psuedo reddit

Is it really a thing to bash Reddit for everything?

I mean, it's not great in general, but the few subreddits I follow are much better than HN, at least nobody is telling you what's good and what is not, it's the community that regulates itself.

Isn't it possible that having a bad experience with Reddit is a “show me who your friends are, and I’ll tell you who you are” more than anything else?

I guess on the one hand if the conversation didn't warrant you returning to it in a timely fashion, maybe it wasn't that critical.

For any company related stuff I usually checked in regularly and also have google alerts set up.

But for casual banter, I think the no notification is a nice feature of HN and probably reduces some of the bad noise other public forums have.

That being said, still a nice feature to add for those who want it =]

I think it will be nice to stay as it is for the most part, but for a comment of your own you should have the ability to enable notifications for direct answers. It would be really useful when I have follow up questions.

Maybe add a limit on how many 'followed threads' you could have active at the same time, so they discourage automating this behavior and make you really think if the thread is that important for you at the moment.

It's true. There is also some interesting gamification in looking at your Karma and trying to figure out why it increased.

Sometimes my karma randomly goes up a bit, and in investigating why, I get to go back and re-enjoy threads on articles because someone replied to something from a while ago, but most of all I like the impetuous is on me to go look for replies, I think it adds a level of friction that makes the HN experience better.

Another free tool in a similar vein is F5Bot. It can monitor HN for keywords and email you whenever they show up.

https://f5bot.com/

I built my own chrome extension for this and also tracking users (similar to an RSS feed). It was actually for a client, don’t know what happened to it. I used it for personal use a bit and frankly I like the untracked and unnamed nature of comments. I don’t need to follow people for thoughtful comments. I add insight where I can and honestly only return if I want to. I don’t need notifications, I’d rather explore organically.

That being said, good work and I’m sure others will find value. Just not for me.

I don't see a privacy policy anywhere.
You could probably do something similar but hosted privately using haxor:

https://github.com/avinassh/haxor

I really like this, I just wish the email was re-arranged a little to make it harder for me to hit the "unsubscribe" link instead of the "go to my post" link
Reminds me of https://histre.com/features/
I went to the developers site from hnreplies.com and an advertisement opened. Hoping this site's revenues ain't ad driven.
That's not good for my addiction.
Right? With everything we know about the main social networks, I’d pass on this too.
Been using HN Replies for years, not sure why anyone comments on HN without it!

Thanks for making a great free product.

I've been using this service for a few months, now. I get enough comments even weeks after my original posts that I've grateful for the notification. So, to the creator, thank you!
I want to know where my upvotes are coming from! Some days the counter is increased by one or two, and there appears to be no activity on my newest comments.
Cool! There was http://www.hnnotify.com for this, same idea (but no longer works)
IMO, reply notifications (configurable on per-thread basis) should have been a part of HN from the very beginning.
I've been happily using this since Jan 2019. Not sure how long it's been around, but it's not new.
I've been wanting to build this for years, thought there must be a reason it doesn't exist aha
This is great work, but I'd prefer an in-page notification (an HN inbox).

I don't want more email.

Nice idea, but as a new user I don't like to be notified! :)
Or as an old one....
My feature request came true :D https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18587562
HN replies has been running since before your post, I've been using it for a few years for sure.
Quote: "1,945 HN Users Signed Up"

Well, well, well. For a crowd that cries each time somebody like Google & Co gets data on users, this does sounds like the best tool to get hold of developers without them realizing they've just been fished :D.

Ignoring the fallacy of equating crowd opinions with individual ones, what "fishing" is happening by explicitly putting data into the signup to this service?