back

by calvinmorrison·5y ago·view on hn ↗
So I'm reading a book called "Empire of Liberty" which covers the 1790's up unto 1812 I believe (not done yet). Anyway, this is not a new problem. In fact, 'seditious libel' was a totally different concept back in the 1790's - we actually have more freedom of speech than before. Without going to much into that - the Alien & Sedition Acts were aimed at this type of newspaper rags. There were many newspapers and operaters that were foreign born, or foreign influenced, peddling influence in the young United States. Part of the motivation of the Federalists was due to a widespread fear of imminent war with France. France and the United States were in the midst of the "Quazi-War" which well, wasn't exactly a war. Democratic-Repubicans (think jefferson and other extremely liberty minded politicians and journalists) were supporters of the French Revolution, and many wanted a similar revolution in the States to remake American society.

Not so many were prosecuted under these acts, but many did flee or change their tone.

This all to say that the influence of newspapers is not a novel issue, and the issue remains alive today, especially amidst the current wave of very Yellow Journalism.

Anyway. I thought it was interesting - I may have botched some of the details.

1 comments
Yeah but there was honest competition among newspapers in those days. There wasn't a total monopoly, or corporate consensus, driving so much of the news cycle. I would argue that's the unique feature of today. We've ordained certain news organizations to be The Authority and they all seem to cover the news in exactly the same way. There's no contrarianism. Just the illusion of choice and variety.
The 'mainstream' media for lack of a better term has built a nicely sized moat around themselves. Remember, if someone has to run ad campaigns about how 'honest' or 'truthful' journalists they are - run away.
I dunno, MSNBC and FOX news seem to come from very different viewpoints.
fair point.

Now let's play this game with MSNBC, Reuters, AP, CNN, ABC, NBC, CBS, PBS, NPR, etc.

Assigning vector values to each of these sources, is it your contention that they too sum to zero?