Item — HN Reader

Genial !

I suggest you expand and better showcase the third usage (add and remove metadata) to demonstrate how powerful this Obsidian->python->Obsidian cycle is.

The way you formulate it makes a big difference. It is a subtle power and people need to visualize it better:

- imagine you can export your metadata to excel/DB, apply all sort of data processing, and merge them again.

- Have you ever wished to batch edit that read-only Dataview result or that db-folder Table?

- What if you could use your DB/excel table dynamically in obsidian, so that rows could bidirectionally be linked to pages? (This is an advanced one, but still indirectly possible)

You can also show how this can efficiently replace a lot of plugins (importing data from API/scraping, Data maintenance...) and a lot more, with simple and personalized python scripts.

Bon courage !

1 comments

Lots of great application ideas, thanks for sharing. I'll think about it when expanding the tutorials.

Same as you, I think it would be nice to have editable dataview tables; but I'm not sure this library is the answer to that. That type of feature should be directly implemented in dataview. I believe the DB-folder plugin solves this problem: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ibarYqG4W5I

But I haven't tested it yet. The video presentation seems very instructive: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ibarYqG4W5I

> editable dataview tables; but I'm not sure this library is the answer to that

No, I used to word "batch edit". DB-folder tables are indeed "editable" but you can't "batch edit" them. Your library allows this further step. that was my point : to show how your solution augment what dataview and DB-folder already offers (augment, not replace)

It seems some people are using https://python-frontmatter.readthedocs.io/en/latest/index.ht... for raw batch editing. (seen here https://forum.obsidian.md/t/bulk-changes-of-markdown-files/1...)

> when expanding the tutorials.

IMO, You can also put python scripts in github for some precise use cases (data maintenance...), to showcase the possibilities.

> IMO, You can also put scripts in github for more precise use cases (data maintenance...), to showcase the possibilities.

That's how I use the library for my personal vault. Its a nice idea to share them as recipe scripts :thumbsup: I'll dig into that.

> It seems some people are using https://python-frontmatter.readthedocs.io/en/latest/index.ht... for raw batch editing

I use that library too, in fact it is the only dependency of py-obsidianmd. It's only used to load the frontmatter though.

> that was my point : to show how your solution augment what dataview and DB-folder already offers (augment, not replace)

That could be a standalone video, indeed. Show a workflow with dataview, and going further with python scripting and py-obsidianmd.

Some plugins are being developed to run python scripts directly within obsidian (https://github.com/mProjectsCode/obsidian-script-runner-plug...),, so one can imagine running his maintenance recipes etc. without leaving the vault. Many possibilities !