back

by NaOH·14y ago·view on hn ↗
I'm curious - do you happen to know whether the essay portions ever offered any actual statistical utility above and beyond the multiple choice ones? As in, do they actually measure anything that the multiple choice questions can't?

I believe written assessments were relatively new to standardized tests when I was in the field. My understanding was that the purpose was to assess writing, just like we do with, say, math or reading comprehension. Multiple-choice questions can't evaluate a student's ability to respond to an open-ended question, convey ideas, stay on topic, demonstrate grammar and punctuation, etc.

But I didn't get the impression that adding writing components to the test added anything of practical value. Sure, it's one more score-based judgment that can be assigned to each student and be used to assess schools and districts, but as far as I could tell it wasn't benefitting student education. And it certainly came with a high price tag. But I was definitely not in classrooms, so that's a key caveat to anything I share.

Does writing seem any better? Well, these written assessments have been widespread for about 20 years or so. I don't get the sense from what I see that people nowadays are generally good writers. But my exposure is certainly limited, even if others I speak to seem to agree, and I'm not certain if enough time has elapsed whereby we would broadly see the effects of such a change in educational assessment.