His education and his upbringing definitely weren't free, they were paid for by his parent's taxes, and he is now repaying society by paying taxes himself (I mean, presumably, obviously if he's dodging taxes then that's a different discussion :P). He doesn't owe society (and let's be real, in this specific topic we're really talking about megacorps with literally trillions of dollars in their coffers wanting to absorb as much data as they can en-masse for free in order to train their toy AIs with which they'll earn a few more trillions off the backs of others) a release of whatever it is he creates for no recompense.
back
1 comments
"He doesn't owe society"
Whether one owes or has an obligation to society or not is the big philosophical divide in society these days. No doubt education and upbringing aren't completely free but formal training is only a small aspect of a citizen's socialization and training, the rest comes from his/her interaction with society—which is free.
"...(and let's be real, in this specific topic we're really talking about megacorps with literally trillions of dollars in their coffers..."
I agree, but this is a separate issue and I should have made a distinction between what one 'owes' society and what megacorps are leeching from society for free.
Then there's the question of how much prior art one has learned (no one creates in a vacuum, one always builds on the works of others, so there's a philosophical argument about how much original content one has actually created).
Look at it this way: megacorps are not only leeching information from society for free (through AI and other means) but also they're 'stealing' once-open stuff from the public domain and making it proprietary on the flimsiest of grounds through questionable patents and trivial copyright—all of which is legal.
Most megacorps are public companies and thus are owned by shareholders who, in turn, are citizens in society. If hef19898 wants AI megacorps etc. to stop stealing his content then he will have to get cooperation from his fellow citizens—many of whom are shareholders in said companies.
Fact is, in the great scheme of things the pecuniary interest of these shareholding citizens holds much greater sway in society than do the moral rights of hef19898 and his ilk.
If this were not so then said megacorps wouldn't be able to 'rape' the defenseless as they have been doing for decades. As I've mentioned, hef19898 and ilk simply don't have the numbers to change things.
It's obvious, there are no masses with placards blocking Pennsylvania Avenue or throngs protesting around the Capitol to bring the megacorps to heel. Until then hef19898 will just have to accept that his content will be stolen.