back

by pentagrama·1y ago·view on hn ↗
A bit off-topic, but this makes me wonder about the relationship between Microsoft and Wine. Do they consider it a threat? An ally? Both?

This is my first time seeing Microsoft acknowledge Wine's existence, and in this case, it was at least in a friendly manner? Or could there be bad faith behind this 'donation'?

3 comments
Another poster quoted Wikipedia somewhere here; MS implicitly acknowledged Wine's existence back in 2005 when they added a check for some of Wine's registry keys which would disable Windows Update if it found them. And in 2020 MS filed an Amicus brief in that Google/Oracle lawsuit in support of free re-implementations of APIs, citing Wine as a positive example.

While I am still wary of Microsoft after their previous anti-competitive behaviors, I think they've taken a more pragmatic view of late, and realize that projects like Wine are actually good for their platform as a whole. I expect if Wine/Proton did not exist, we'd see more (for example) Windows-only games ported to macOS or Linux. With Wine/Proton, those ports are mostly not necessary, and Microsoft gets to say that Win32/DirectX is something of a cross-platform gaming "standard".

What could WINE possibly do to them? Rob them of all kinds of enterprise and cloud business? WINE is a single LED on a nuclear powerplant control panel.
The best Wine environment is still a Windows install. You need a lot of things to do to run some of the mill Win32 app, so Wine is not a direct threat for MS in any foreseeable future.