Minecraft is extremely mismanaged, the fact that the java version is still the ”main” version after all these years is just crazy
back
2 comments
Why is it crazy? Any rewrite that would be as flexible wrt mods would be shaped similarly.
Java garbage collection gets out of control when cramming 100+ poorly optimized mods together. The bedrock edition is great in theory but the proper mod API never appeared. Regardless, people have accomplished some really impressive stuff with commands, but it is an exercise in pain.
The other issue with bedrock is it is far from feature parity with java. If these two things were hit then java could be reasonably retired. However we are decades too late in it being acceptable to introduce a breaking change to mod loading. So it's java forever.
Java garbage collection is what's allowing those 100+ poorly optimize mods to be functional at the same time in the first place.
Games with robust modding will almost always feature a garbage collected language which is what's primarily used for the modding.
Consider this, if the mod interface was C/C++, do you think those poorly optimized mods could be trusted to also not leak memory?
>Consider this, if the mod interface was C/C++, do you think those poorly optimized mods could be trusted to also not leak memory?
Of course. Because they would fail loudly and would have to be fixed in order to run. Garbage collection is a crutch which lets broken things appear not broken.
Memory leaks very often don't fail loudly. Especially if they are slower leaks which don't immediately break the application.
A lot of the memory problems that you can see without a GC are hard to find and diagnose. Use after free, for example, is very often safe. It only crashes or causes problems sometimes. Same for double free. And they are hard to diagnose because the problems they do create are often observed at a distance. Use after free will silently corrupt some bit of memory somewhere else, what trips up on it might be completely unrelated.
It's the opposite of failing loudly.
> A lot of the memory problems that you can see without a GC are hard to find and diagnose
The nastiest leak I've ever seen in a C++ production system happened inside the allocator. We had a really hostile allocation pattern that forced the book-keeping structures inside the allocator to grow over time.
To be fair, I've seen something similar with the JVM, though it recovers. G1GC when it was first introduced would create these massive bookkeeping structures in order to run collections. We are talking about off JVM heap memory allocations up to 20% of the JVM heap allocation.
It's since gotten a lot better with JVM updates, so much so that it's not a problem in Java 21 and 25.
> Consider this, if the mod interface was C/C++, do you think those poorly optimized mods could be trusted to also not leak memory?
Garbage collection does not solve memory leak problems. For example
- keeping a reference too long,
- much more subtle: having a reference to some object inside some closure
will also cause memory leaks in a garbage-collected language.
The proper solution is to consider what you name "poorly optimized mods" to be highly experimental (only those who are of very high quality can be treated differently).
> Garbage collection does not solve memory leak problems
It solves a class of memory leak problems which are much harder to address without the GC. Memory lifetimes.
It's true that you can still create an object that legitimately lives for the duration of the application, nothing solves that.
But what you can't do is allocate something on the heap and forget to free it. Or double free it. Or free it before the actual lifetime has finished.
Those are much trickier problems to solve which experienced C/C++ programmers trip over all the time. It's hard enough to have been the genesis of languages like Java and Rust.
I do wonder then how difficult it would be to mod games written in D
I don't think D has a "must use GC" mode, so probably easy to hit a footgun. It's the footguns that make things hard (IMO).
I always had trouble running bedrock as a household server. Specifically it would stop accepting connections and required daily restarts. Java was much more reliable.
You're right. Hytale is certainly shaped similarly in that regard.
Have you played Bedrock? It sucks.