back

by matheusmoreira·6d ago·view on hn ↗
> in order to democratise it

Don't believe that even for a second.

> move towards communism

Has never happened, and I don't believe it ever will.

We have better chances of collapsing capitalism from within.

1 comments
> We have better chances of collapsing capitalism from within.

Isn't that what Marx says? Capitalism is unstable and collapses from within. He identifies socialism as the next stage (seizing the means of production) that then leads to communism (fully distributed ownership and no real state).

We may of course disagree that these stages are what would actually happen. So far when the state seizes the means of production, it becomes highly authoritarian and doesn't want to relinqish power and move towards actual communism.

It's possible that Marx was right about that specifically, and that capitalism will destroy itself naturally through sheer technological innovation by automating everything to the point economics becomes irrelevant.

I'm deeply suspicious of any socialist or communist who desires to implement a socialist state, however. His prophecy must come true naturally, it cannot be forced via government mandates.

Socialists want to get rid of capitalism as the economic model and then transition to post scarcity. I want to keep capitalism until it destroys itself by making everything abundant and automated.

There is no need to "seize" anything. We merely need personal manufacturing technology.

Personal manufacturing tech isnt something he envisaged I guess!

Still need food, water, energy and raw materials though. Some kind of collective action seems needed, however that is arranged politically.