back

by jay_kyburz·13y ago·view on hn ↗
I wish somebody from Google would just search his inbox for the "Google OS" from April 07 and put an end to this discussion.

If it's there then Antoine should have known about it. Why wasn't Chrome build on top of this Google OS. Why hasn't he heard of this guy.

2 comments
Peter Kasting did it. Just check the G+ comments.

"I have a copy of a May 18, 2007 (not April) email from Jeff announcing his project on a wide-distribution list. It does not have the subject line "Google OS"; it's actually called "Guppy needs testers". Given that it begins, "I'd like to publish my Linux distro, called Guppy, for some testers to try out and provide feedback. Guppy is a little side project to build a Google distro of PuppyLinux for USB.", I'm inclined to believe it's the first such wide-distribution email. The phrase "Google OS" is never mentioned; neither are "browser" or "Chrome" or "Firefox" or "webapps". The closest we get is the single sentence two thirds of the way through that "I set up some desktop shortcuts to Google Apps", which is literally the only time the email mentions anything close to Jeff's claim above that "all of the functionality came from webapps; performing any operation on the desktop launched a Chrome window to one of many webapps." In fact, the email explicitly mentions that you can install OpenOffice if you want, which seems to contradict this portrayal a bit."

Google is a big place. There can be multiple people working on similar ideas (see Chrome OS and Android). If the projects are small it would be common for them to not even know about each other, at least for a little while.

If you tried to enforce that everyone who wanted to work on similar things had to work together you would burn a lot of energy arguing about "similar" and relatively minor differences in direction.

Sometimes it is easier and better to just let there be separate efforts and the market (both the internal attention market, and in extreme cases, the external actual market) can decide.