back

by dcminter·13y ago·view on hn ↗
They're all reading novels, listening to the wireless, watching TV, on facebook, ...

The great novelists and great artists of today are lost in the noise. When history has thrown away the chaff they'll be visible - and people will be complaining about the low quality of their own contemporaries.

1 comments
> When history has thrown away the chaff they'll be visible

Tolstoy was famous in his day. As was Dostoevsky, Hemingway, Picasso, etc. Sure there were a few, like Van Gogh, who died before becoming recognized, but they were fractional exceptions.

Show me one great artist living today -- anyone who can compete with a Tolstoy or even a Hemingway. Below Cormac McCarthy and Jonathan Franzen are mentioned, but I don't think anyone in their right mind would put them remotely at that level. You're waiting for history and there's no sign that you'll do anything but keep waiting.

I can think of lots of candidates for our contemporary historic greats - but you can easily defeat this argument by assessing them as less great than your own historic heroes.

You and I will never know. But I'm betting that the contemporary distractions are no more the cause of mediocrity than the historic ones were.