back
9 comments
Another not so widely known fact is the history of Jewish population in India. They predate their settlement in Europe. If you visit Cochin, Kerala you would find one of the oldest synagogues there, inlaid with beautiful porcelain tiles imported from China, all hand made and hand painted, and hence unique - a must visit.

People make a great leap of generalization when they make the case for anti-semitism (I do dislike that word, it does not mean what it literally means) to be a uniform phenomena. It was categorically lacking in India. In fact many a Indian not so educated in world history would go "Huh!" in bewilderment if one makes such a claim. I find many Jewish people in US are unaware of this history, particularly the right wing kind.

I remember attending a Jewish student gathering organized to mourn the death of a Mumbai Rabbi killed in the Mumbai terrorist attack. Us new Indian students left with a lot of head scratching because of the strong singular rhetoric that permeated the gathering. It was that of Jewish population being persecuted everywhere (hinting that the same is true in India and in particular was true for the Rabbi) and the need to stand up, resist and confront that. Not a word about others who lost their lives in that terrorist incident.

It was a bit awkward. No ill feelings, just a bit of head-scratching "OK, if you say so" bizarre.

Ironically, the Bene Israel (Indian Jews) often face severe discrimination from other Jewish groups when they go to Israel[0] .

Because they have been in India for so long, they don't "look" Jewish (ie, not like Ashkenazi or Sephardic or Mezrahi groups), so they aren't considered "real" Jews. Only recently have they been able to "prove" their status with blood tests.

It's all very sad.

[0] http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bene_Israel

> It's all very sad.

Indeed, ironic perhaps because Israel commits some of the same mistakes against minorities as many Israeli citizens experienced as a minority group themselves in other countries.

The plight of the Ethiopian jews in Israel (Beta Israel) for example is riddled with controversy. Just recently there was the birth-control issue[0] which is quite shameful.

[0] http://www.forbes.com/sites/eliseknutsen/2013/01/28/israel-f...

It is almost astoundingly comical how the xenophobia & generally retrograde thinking of some elements in Israel, barely gets a mention, in mainstream American media narratives.

Racist Israelis Protest Against African Refugees! "N*ggers Go Home"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2ohJD7-zi7U

(Israelis, in Tel Aviv, protest a High Court ruling that declared internment camps for African refugees are unconstitutional)

Edit: Reversed word choice

Wow, that is messed up. I though Israel as a society was way more aware of such issues. I don't think you'd see something like that in Europe today either.
Similar for Chinese Jews.
This is great, I think we get so caught up with the caricatures and stereo-types, such authentic collection that tells stories and sets context opens our mind to the distances people traveled even in those old days and how open minded people were even then.
"Rare images" and "rare footage" are common phrases in linkbait. It's a particularly ham-fisted attempt to sensationalise a topic. The idea fails to make sense at a very basic level. An image can be duplicated. Scarcity doesn't apply. So images can't be rare. In time to come we'll see awkward attempts to redefine the meaning of 'rare' so as to contain this awful usage.
You can't have ever had a difficult time finding a particular image, or sometimes any image of a particular thing before. In the case of footage, I've spent years trying to find footage that I knew existed at some point (based on somebody's writing, or from stills in a book), but short of getting access to some archive and flying (internationally) there to search through boxes, I not only can't find it, but can't even verify that it still exists.

Just because a thing can be duplicated doesn't mean it has been, and just because something was once available doesn't mean you'll have any luck finding it today.