I certainly agree that whether it meets the requirements is important (debatable whether it's more important than design/quality).
I'm just saying it's not the concern of a code review.
1 comments
Am I the only person who works in a place with very half arsed requirements? I have to take a guess a lot of the time as to what management actually want form what they say. Code quality matters 6 moths later when they say it isn't working (as expected) and I have to check what the code actually is doing.